Truth or Consequences
Did you know that there is a city called “Truth or Consequences, New Mexico”? Yep, the city, formerly known as “Hot Springs, New Mexico”, renamed itself after a radio game show called “Truth or Consequences” in 1950. It was a wise move on the part of the city who gained lots of attention from the name change and the ensuing fame that came with it.
Consequences are often thought of as negative. In the game show above, if a contestant answered a question incorrectly, they were required to pay a penalty (usually
they performed a silly, embarrassing or messy stunt.) But consequences are not always negative. Merriam-Webster says a consequence is: a result, effect, or conclusion produced by a preceding cause, action, or set of conditions.
So, there are as many positive consequences as there are negative. For example, the result of an adult working a fulltime job is earning a paycheck to purchase the things they want or need. The result of cleaning up one’s toys is being able to find what you’re looking for next time you want to play with it or having a calm space to relax when you’re tired. Or, if a child puts their shoes on when asked, they can go outside to play with their friends!
At St. Paul’s Day School we teach about both kinds of consequences, and the children adjust their behavior based on their understanding of the sort of consequence they would like. Consistency is the secret to helping children begin to choose a “thumbs up” option. When the child gets the same result from their action or behavior over and over, they know what to expect. We help them by naming expectations before there is a consequence, which allows them to choose.
Here’s a sweet example. One of our three-year-olds is very affectionate. He loves to hug. But in the beginning of the year, he often barreled into the teacher or blindsided a friend without warning and there were several mishaps. Children knocked over, tears, teachers who firmly set the little one back as they explained why the wild hugging wasn’t safe. He now understands he can ask, “can I give you a hug?” and the “consequence” is a delighted smile and a “yes!”
Our little ones are earning smiles and high fives as they choose to use “their words” and good manners and gentle hands. As the teachers and I affirm the appropriate actions and choices, the children strive to please. They are still three- and four-year olds, so sometimes they make mistakes. But the more consistent we are with consequences, the more often they choose to earn a positive reward!
Pro Tip from Mrs. Ryan
Sometimes the best way to help a child make the right choice, is to praise another child who is doing the right thing. “Wow, I love the way Bobby is listening to the story! Thank you Bobby!”





As I read about the antics of the “Naughty Little Monkeys”, they started jockeying for position, moving in front of one another to see the pages better. Then scooting the mats too close together, finally overlapping and causing territorial disputes. We were up to the monkey who was jumping on his bed and the one who was chewing gum and blowing bubbles that got all over the quilt and her sibling (all to the delight of the children being read to) when the first parent arrived. I put down the book, and we all rushed out to unlock the gate, say goodbye and lock the gate when he left. Then I herded them in and got them settled and re-started the story.





